Plato s arguments against democracy

Recall in the Apology that Socrates was tried and sentenced to death by the men of Athens. While Plato thus describes the liberating and empowering nature of education, he was deeply pessimistic with regard to its popularity. The poor underclass grows and many of them become either beggars or thugs imbued with anger at their condition and a revolutionary spirit which threatens the stability of the state from within.

The turbulent democracy were quickly replaced by a new and even more brutal military dictatorship. Unless the philosophers rule as kings or those now called kings and chiefs genuinely and adequately philosophize, and political power and philosophy coincide in the same place, while the many natures now making their way to either apart from the other are by necessity excluded, there is no rest from ills for the cities, my dear Glaucon, nor I think for human kind, nor will the regime we have now described in speech ever come forth from nature, insofar as possible, and see the light of the sun.

The former president of Singapore, Lee Kuan Yew, has stated that such disciplined states like his Singapore, South Korea and China under Deng Xiao Peng and his successors, have had a strong economic growth, precisely because they have stable governments and do not give free rein for advanced democracy and tolerance.

It is the purpose of democracy to make decisions when these disagreements arise. His clear message was that Athens lost the war, because it was a democracy.

Plato's five regimes

Assuming that the Republic was intended to be a serious critique of the political thought in Athens, Plato argues that only Kallipolisan aristocracy led by the unwilling philosopher-kings the wisest menis a just form of government. If we held elections under such circumstances, it would result in a fundamentalist government, violence and terror, just as in Algiers.

University of Notre Dame Press, The unreasonable persons in society need not agree with the terms of association arrived at by reasonable persons in order for those terms to be legitimate.

The Failure of Democracy Plato is often described as the greatest Western philosopher. First, Plato Republic, Book VI argued that some people are more intelligent and more moral than others and that those persons ought to rule.

Of course, I may also believe Plato s arguments against democracy such a society must be democratically organized in which case I will attempt to advance these principles through the democratic process.

They would not have been able to maintain a strategy through hardship and temporary defeats. The democratic man takes great interest in all the things he can buy with his money.

One argument is an epistemological one. It was the first blow to the socialist systems in Eastern Europe in modern times. One of their very first actions was to involve Denmark in the wars over Slesvig and Holsten, which for hundred of years had been ruled by the Danish kings.

They should just concentrate on their jobs and their private lives. One difficulty is that this view relies on agreement much as the liberty views described above.

One only offers principles that others, who restrain themselves in the same way, can accept. In his time the democratic Athens and the kingdom of Sparta kingdom fought "The Peloponnesian War", which lasted 27 years.

In our time is a huge geographical and social mobility. An oligarchy will usually do poorly in military campaigns because the rich, who are few, will make a small army, and they are afraid to give weapons to the majority the poor due to fears of a revolution.A dangerous opponent of democracy?

Plato's views in the Republic. By Catherine Osborne Omnibus 26, SeptemberIn the Republic Plato compares the nature of the human individual to the members of a state. Instrumental Arguments against Democracy. Not all instrumental arguments favor democracy.

Plato (Republic, Book VI) argues that democracy is inferior to various forms of monarchy, aristocracy and even oligarchy on the grounds that democracy tends to undermine the expertise necessary to properly governed societies.

In a democracy, he. Plato S Arguments Against Democracy 1. Democracy is a form of government where people choose leaders through elections and social construct that are based on the equality of everyone within the state. "The best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter." - Winston Churchill The discussion of which polity is best goes back to Plato's Republic and Aristotle.

Neither one of these men advocated democracy, but they also feared despotism. "The best argument against democracy is a five-minute.

Events Calendar

Plato, however, does present a criticism against those cities — that their constitutions neglected two other virtues essential to a perfectly just city such as his aristocracy, namely wisdom and moderation.

The Case Against Democracy Plato, one of the earliest to see democracy as a problem, saw its typical citizen as shiftless and flighty: The second argument against epistocracy would be to.

Plato s arguments against democracy
Rated 3/5 based on 41 review