Problems in defining and measuring crime

These values were displayed to the respondents in a show card. Lynch explores a number of differences between the two studies, including: For example, a survey by Koss, Gidycz, and Wisniewski included five items designed to elicit reports of attempted or completed rape.

Looking for other ways to read this?

One of the reasons that bounding procedures, like the one used in the NCVS, are thought to be effective is that they convey to respondents the need for precision cf. A number of other national surveys have also recorded whether other people are present during the interviews, but researchers who have examined these data have found little evidence that the presence of others affects reports about such potentially sensitive topics as sexual behavior Laumann et al.

Over the past 15 years or so, survey researchers have begun to apply findings from the cognitive sciences, particularly cognitive psychology, in a systematic program to understand reporting errors in surveys see Sirken et al.

What is somewhat surprising is that the rate of overreporting did not vary as a function of the privacy of the interview. In one study Beebe et al. Respondents may also draw unintended inferences based on other features of the questions or their order.

Discuss the Problems of Defining Crime and Deviance

Biderman and Cantor, The demands of interpreting this item, mentally implementing its complicated logical requirements, and searching memory for relevant incidents over such a long period are likely to exceed the working memory capacity of many respondents, even well-motivated ones Just and Carpenter, Despite the methodological differences between the two surveys, the difference between the two estimates is probably not significant.

Overall, the Kleck items yielded three times more reports of defensive gun use than the NCVS-style items. As the Oxford English Dictionary states it is a crime to cause injury to public welfare, so is the army, when at war committing a crime according to that definition?

If the sample accurately reflects this underlying distribution, then only 1 percent of Problems in defining and measuring crime are in the position to underreport defensive gun use; the remaining 99 percent can only overreport it.

They sometimes lean on relatively subtle cues—the numbers assigned to the scale points, the order of the questions, the arrangement of the response categories—to make inferences about the intent behind the questions and about their job as respondents.

For the moment, let us accept the view that 1 percent of all adults used a gun to defend themselves against a crime over the past year. IMPACT OF CONTEXT The context of a survey question encompasses a wide range of potential influences, including the perceived climate of opinion as the survey is being done, the auspices under which the survey is conducted, the purpose of the survey as it is presented to the respondentthe topics preceding a given question, characteristics of the interviewers related to the survey topic, the physical setting for the interview, and even the weather see Schwarz and Clore, In another study Moon,respondents were sensitive to the description of the computer that administered the questions.

There are several possible explanations for the absence of third-party effects. For example, if the speaker seems to have changed the topic, the listener will assume there is some connection with what came before and will attempt to identify the thread.

As with the estimates of defensive gun use, what is surprising is not that the estimates differ from each other but that they differ so widely. The problem with defining crime is that there is no definitive answer and we need to examine the cultural, social, economical, religious and political factors that influence and shape the definition of crime.

Their estimate was based on data from the NCVS, which gathers information about several classes of crime—rape, assault, burglary, personal and household larceny, and car theft.

Still, a couple of more recent studies suggest that answers to survey questions can be affected by the physical setting in which the data are collected.

Get instant access to over 50, essays. In his discussion of the controversy over estimates of defensive gun use, Hemenway makes the same point.

Several studies converge on the estimate that about one-quarter of American women have been victims of completed or attempted rape at some time in their lives see, for example, Koss, There were twice as many positive answers to the rape screening questions as there were incidents ultimately classified as rapes based on the detailed reports.

Login Deviancy when an illegal act is committed is called formal deviancy but when no criminal act is committed then it is called informal deviancy. One theme that clearly emerges from this literature is that respondents take whatever shortcuts they can to reduce the cognitive effort needed to answer the questions see, for example, Krosnick and Alwin, ; Krosnick, There are probably several reasons for this.

What are respondents likely to conclude about the intent of a survey like the NCVS? Based on their experiences in other settings, respondents may have Page 25 Share Cite Suggested Citation: Tourangeau, Rips, and Rasinski argue that what survey respondents worry about is that they will be embarrassed during an interview; the prototypical embarrassment situation involves disclosure to strangers rather than friends or family members Tangney et al.

The proportion varied somewhat from one survey to the next, but roughly half of all interviews conducted between and were done in the presence of another household member Silver et al.

As a result, the correlation between the two items can be sharply reduced as compared to when they are separated in the interview see also Schwarz et al. In the first place, as Cannell, Fowler, and Marquis noted more than 30 years ago, respondents may simply not realize they are supposed to work hard and provide exact, accurate information.

Even when respondents do not have to interact with an interviewer, the characteristics of the data collection setting can enhance or reduce the sense of privacy and affect the answers that respondents give.

The study is conducted by the Bureau of the Census, the source of many important official statistics, on behalf of another federal agency, the Bureau of Justice.

Still, the difference between 65, incidents a year and someis quite dramatic and would seem to demand a less mundane explanation than one involving routine methodological differences.

Self-administration of the questions is likely to increase the number of rape victimizations reported; on the other hand, it may sharply reduce reports of defensive gun use, since defensive gun use is likely to be seen as a positive or socially desirable response to crime as Hemenway,argues.

What all of these findings suggest is that crime reports—especially reports about victimizations involving crimes that carry stigma—could be dramatically affected by the mode of data collection.This assignment will discuss the problems between crime and deviance, what counts as crime and deviance and how it varies with place and time.

It will include the difference and similarities and give examples of defining crime and deviance. Finally the essay moves on to looking at how to identify. Defining crime is problematic as it is a social construct and therefore heavily reliant on the context in which it is set.

Simply put, crime is seen as an act against the community, which requires a legal punishment. In UK law, crime is determined when a guilty act (actus reus), violates the law.

Start studying Problems in measuring crime. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Today we will be looking at the difference between crime and deviance, the way of measuring crime and deviance and the problems involved.

Defining crime is complex, dependant on social, political and economic factors. Crime is an act punishable by law. If somebody breaks the law, whether it is a. Crime "Breaking the laws of society" (Legalistic definition) Problems in defining crime: Historical Context - At one point in time, things were illegal and are now legal.

Read chapter 2. Measuring Crime and Crime Victimization: Methodological Issues: Most major crime in this country emanates from two major data sources. The.

Download
Problems in defining and measuring crime
Rated 4/5 based on 46 review